Best Online Leads · Higher Education

Most universities buy inquiries and let them die.

Your next enrolled student is already in your CRM — waiting 42 hours for a call back. We help enrollment teams find more of the right prospects, on channels your competitors aren't using, and respond before those prospects move on.

Start the Conversation Why Speed Wins
100x
more likely to connect when you respond in 5 minutes vs. 30
21x
more likely to qualify the lead with a 5-minute response
23%
of companies never respond to a web inquiry at all
42 hrs
the average company's first response time
The 5-minute rule

Speed wins enrollments.

Harvard Business Review mystery-shopped 2,241 companies: 23% never responded to a web inquiry at all. Average first response time: 42 hours.

The underlying research is even sharper — reaching out within 5 minutes instead of 30 makes you roughly 100x more likely to connect and 21x more likely to qualify the lead.

In enrollment terms: every inquiry your team touches tomorrow instead of today is a student who already moved on. Usually to the school that called back first.

  • Audit your current inquiry response time
  • Build follow-up that answers in minutes, not days
  • Stop wasting the inquiries you've already paid for
Speed to lead: the 5-minute rule infographic

Sources: James Oldroyd, Lead Response Management Study, InsideSales.com (2007) · Oldroyd, McElheran & Elkington, “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads,” Harvard Business Review (Mar 2011)

What we do

Two levers. One goal: more enrolled students.

Ad spend gets the budget line. Follow-up speed gets the shrug. It should be the other way around — so we work both ends of your funnel.

◎

Untapped Ad Channels

Your prospective students spend hours every day on platforms your media plan ignores. We open advertising channels most enrollment teams have never run a campaign on — precisely targeted and fully measurable, with no minimum spend to get started.

◷

Speed-to-Lead Follow-Up

Inquiries decay by the hour. We help you build the coverage and systems so every inquiry gets a human response in minutes — including contact-center support for teams that can't staff it alone.

▣

Enrollment Outcomes

No vanity metrics. We track the numbers your board actually asks about: inquiries worked, conversations held, students enrolled. If it doesn't move enrollment, it doesn't make the report.

Two practices, one firm

This page is about higher education.
We also grow local businesses.

Our Local & Ecommerce practice — led by Josh Spencer — runs Facebook & Instagram advertising for local service businesses and Shopify/DTC brands: lead generation, ecommerce growth, creative, and automation.

See Josh's Work

Dr. Jay Spencer, Founder & Executive Consultant

Jay has spent his career inside higher-education enrollment — building campaigns, working alongside university marketing teams, and learning what actually moves an inquiry from “interested” to enrolled.

Best Online Leads is his consultancy for enrollment leaders who are done paying for clicks and ready to pay attention to what happens after the click: the channels, the follow-up speed, and the operations that turn inquiries into students.

Based in Lynchburg, Virginia — working with colleges and universities nationwide.

Josh Spencer — Meta Advertising, Local & Ecommerce Practice

Josh leads our Local & Ecommerce practice, running Facebook and Instagram advertising for local service businesses and Shopify/DTC brands. See selected work →

Contact

Let's talk about your funnel.

Tell me where inquiries are leaking — I'll tell you honestly whether I can help.

Email Jay Directly